So apparently you can't boil milk?

Posted on April 10, 2007 at 1:25 AM in 'Dear Diary' with tags 'cooking, oatmeal'

Enthused by Meg's suggestion, I bought a tin of McCann's Steel-Cut Oatmeal and determined to try making some oatmeal on the stovetop. The instructions on the tin call for sprinkling 1 cup of oatmeal into 4 cups of briskly boiling water, but I wanted to try it with milk. I also didn't need to make four servings, so I halved the recipe and set 2 cups of milk in a pot on high heat to boil. In less than a minute, the milk poofed up and shot out of the pot and poured all over the stove. Sigh. I'm getting way too familiar with the process of cleaning this stove.

Later in the day I decided to try again, using water as the recipe prescribes, with no variation other than halving the ingredients. It still tried to boil over, but I was able to control it and keep most of it in the pot by lifting the pot off the burner for a few seconds to let the bubbles fall back down. Still, the attempt was a failure. The instructions on the tin say to stir the oatmeal into the boiling water and continue stirring until the porridge becomes smooth and starts to thicken. At that point, you're supposed to lower the heat and let it simmer for 30 minutes, stirring occasionally. Conspicuously absent from the instructions, however, is some estimation of how long it should take for the porridge to become smooth and start to thicken.

I stirred for about 20 minutes before it started to look like something other than grains in a pot of water. At that point, in the span of a few minutes it quickly started looking quite a bit like oatmeal. I lowered the heat and let it simmer, though it looked pretty good already and I was tempted to just take it off the stove as it was. But I had learned my lesson about deviating from the recipe — I was determined to follow its lead to the letter this time.

After five minutes on low heat, the porridge was starting to look dried out and crackly and gross, so I took it off the stove and threw it away with a sigh. What the hell, how can it be so hard to make something that consists of nothing but grain and water?

I did some more searching and found a site that estimates that the first step should only take about 4-6 minutes. My 'porridge' still looked quite a bit like a pot of water with crap in it at that point, but I suppose tomorrow I'll give it another shot and lower the heat after six minutes and see how that turns out.

Comments

Posted by Susan 6 hours, 9 minutes later

OK, this is weird because I'm not known for my cooking... but this is what I do with oatmeal. I put 1/3 cup oatmeal, 1/3 cup milk, 1/3 cup of water, and a little bit of salt, in a rather large bowl and microwave for about 2 minutes or until it looks like oatmeal. Then I add lots of brown sugar. Good luck.

Posted by Antonio 6 hours, 35 minutes later

"It still tried to boil over, but I was able to control it and keep most of it in the pot by lifting the pot off the burner for a few seconds to let the bubbles fall back down."

This is exactly how I cook my pasta.

Posted by Jenn 7 hours, 23 minutes later

While letting the oatmeal simmer, did you leave the lid on? There also has to be enough liquid still in the pot to keep it from burning at a low boil. AFTER something simmers, if it needs to thicken you normally let it stand for a few minutes.

Also, there are different kinds of oats which may take longer or shorter to cook. Thus, it's generally a good idea to stick to the package directions. Next time pick up some quick-cooking oats-- they generally cook in about a minute and then stand.

Oh, and if you want to boil milk, you can, but you can do so on medium heat usually. Keep it stirring!

Posted by Dan 48 minutes later

No, I didn't leave the lid on. I actually don't have a lid for my pot (been meaning to get one), but the instructions on the tin didn't say anything about covering it, so I figured it'd be OK.

I know steel-cut oats take longer, but I specifically bought these because they're supposed to taste better and my goal here is to find the most delicious bowl of oatmeal :) So I don't want to go with rolled oats or microwaves or anything. I'm determined to figure out how the hell to make this work. :)

Good to know about the milk. I might try using milk again after I manage to produce a bowl of oatmeal the standard way.

Posted by Jenn 38 minutes later

See if this helps: http://video.about.com/lowfatcooking/Oatmeal.htm Different kinds of oats but the principle should be the same.

Posted by ... 7 hours, 31 minutes later

Nice site. Thanks.

Posted by Antonio 17 minutes later

You're welcome.

Posted by Antonio 0 minutes later

Echooo....

Posted by Dan 20 minutes later

I wish you'd stop replying to my spam so I can't delete it :)

Posted by Feranando 11 hours, 8 minutes later

Here is an easy recipe that I use at home. We use instant oatmeal. Pour 1 cup of milk in a pot, add 6 teaspoon of instant oatmeal, a pinch of salt, two teaspoons of sugar (or 1 of Splenda) and two drops of vanilla extract. Turn the heat to High and constantly (and I mean constantly) stir until desired consistency. Serve on a plate to cool down until eatable and sprinkle cinnamon powder. Enjoy...

Posted by Hugh1e 2 days, 17 hours later

Porridge and spam - no thank you.

Here's an old scouting trick.

On the embers of your evening campfire boil a pan of water.

While it boils, dig a hole big enough for the pan and line well with straw.

Add the oats to the boiling water.

Put on the lid - yes you will have to get a lid - and put the pan in the hole, covering it with another thick layer of straw.

Have a comfortable night in your down filled sleeping bag on the oh so comfortable ground.

Dig up the pan and serve whilst still hot.

To bring the trick up to date how about pouring the boiling mixture into a wide mouthed vacuumm flask and let it stand for a couple of hours. I've never done it but I bet it would be great.

Posted by Amy 1 day, 11 hours later

So - the best way to heat milk is in a double-boiler (a small pot that rests above the real pot, which contains water). The water from the big pot boils and creates steam, which is able to heat the milk without scalding it (or making it explode in your case). But then again . . . there is always instant oatmeal :)